>>> >Does anyone know if there are specific converters for certain lenses,
>>> >other than a Sigma with a Sigma. I am looking for one for my 70-300???
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> Sometimes it has to do with the aperture of the lens and not the focal
> length. Not sure, however.
I have wondered about the same thing.
I have successfully used a Tamron 2X 7MC Teleconverter with my Sigma 28 -
300 DG on a Cannon XT but I don't get AF, which was not too much of a
setback since I didn;t have AF even when used with a Tamron 28 - 200 on my
old Rebel film camera.
Bill - 08 Jul 2006 23:04 GMT
>>>> >Does anyone know if there are specific converters for certain lenses,
>>>> >other than a Sigma with a Sigma. I am looking for one for my 70-300???
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
>
>I have wondered about the same thing.
When you add a teleconverter, it not only magnifies or adds focal
length, it also decreases the effective aperture of the lense by a
relative amount, increasing the f-stop of the lense.
The smaller effective aperture reduces the amount of light that hits the
autofocus sensors, and if the light level drops too much, the camera can
not focus properly - just as if you were trying to focus in dim light.
With most cameras, the critical level for autofocus is f/5.6 or better.
Some pro level bodies can autofocus with a bit less light.
>I have successfully used a Tamron 2X 7MC Teleconverter with my Sigma 28 -
>300 DG on a Cannon XT but I don't get AF, which was not too much of a
>setback since I didn;t have AF even when used with a Tamron 28 - 200 on my
>old Rebel film camera.
This is typical behaviour.
A 2x teleconverter drops light transmission by 2 stops. So an f/2.8
lense acts like an f/5.6 and a camera body can still autofocus just
fine. But if you have an f/4 and add a 2x, then the light drops off too
much and you get an effective f/8 aperture - not enough light for the
autofocus sensors.
If you use a 1.4x teleconverter, which adds 1 stop, to an f/4 lense, you
get an effective f/5.6 so once again it still focuses ok.
Jim Nagy - 09 Jul 2006 00:58 GMT
> >> I am questiong info from Sigma sight that indicates that you can only
> >> use the 2x on certain lenses, I have the 70=300 and it is not one of
> >> the lenses listed. The 70-200 is I'm trying to find out if the fact
> >> that it is not listed means I can't use it.
<snip>
> > Sometimes it has to do with the aperture of the lens and not the focal
> > length. Not sure, however.
That's true for maintaining auto-focus, but there can be physical
limitations as well. I have the Sigma 1.4x and the 2x, that I normally
use with the Sigma 70-200. I believe that its my Canon 100-300 that
needs to a 12mm extension tube between them so that the rear element of
the Canon lens doesn't hit the front element of the Sigma converter (it
moves in and out as you zoom). Technically, they would be termed
incompatible. They work optically - it's teh physical part that is the
trouble.

Signature
Jim Nagy
Elm Electronics