Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
PhotoKB Home
Discussion Groups
Digital Photography
Digital PhotoDSLR CamerasZLR CamerasPoint & Shoot Cameras
Film Photography
35 mmLarge FormatMedium formatDarkroomFilm and LabsOther Equipment
Photo Technique
Nature PhotographyPeople PhotographyTechnique General
General Photo Topics
General TopicsAustralian PhotographyUK Photography
DirectoryPhoto Clubs

Photo Forum / Film Photography / Darkroom / February 2005

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

KRST questions

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Stephan Goldstein - 26 Feb 2005 13:58 GMT
I have a batch of Kodak Rapid Selenium Toner 1:9 mixed several years
ago.  I last used it maybe 18 months ago and it has been stored at
room temperature in an amber glass bottle since then.  The other
day I pulled it out to tone some prints and noticed a black residue
around the lowest 1" of the bottle.  It seemed to tone OK, I got the
slight color shift I was expecting after 3 minutes, but I'm wondering:

1) what's the storage life of KRST at stock strength?

2) what's the storage life of KRST at working solution strength?

3) would I be better off storing in plastic than in glass?

Thanks to all.

Steve

For direct email replies you'll need to interchange the letter "o" and
the numeral "0" to the left of the yahoo.
Lloyd Erlick - 26 Feb 2005 16:34 GMT
>I have a batch of Kodak Rapid Selenium Toner 1:9 mixed several years
>ago.  I last used it maybe 18 months ago and it has been stored at
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
>Steve
...

feb2605 from Lloyd Erlick,

I've got an article on my website about selenium toner.
Look under the 'technical' heading in the table of
contents. I keep meaning to add to this article, in
light of what I've observed regarding the length of
time I can keep my --and yours too, I see -- jug of
KRST working soilution.

In my opinion, a diluted working solution of selenium
toner (I use KRST) can be stored for years. I'm tempted
to say indefinitely. I'm not so sure this applies to
greater dilutions, like 1+20 or 1+43. I work with KRST
diluted 1+5, and my working solution is several years
old, with a couple of lengthy periods of idleness
included. I think an actively used solution should last
indefinitely because it will be depleted much more
rapidly by solution carry-out on the sheets than by any
other factor. I continually replenish mine by topping
up to my usual volume with fresh KRST diluted 1+5.

The black material seems to be quite inherent to KRST.
I've seen tiny piles of wee crystals of it in the
bottom of unopened one gallon jugs of KRST concentrate.
I think it's something that will come out of solution
over time. I am presuming it is the same stuff as you
see in your container. And I am also presuming (not a
chemist!) that it is the dark material that
precipitates in my working solution, eventually murking
it up so much I hate to use it. It also adheres
tenaciously to the walls of my storage jug.

I've found a nearly complete solution to the black
precipitate in KRST. It's an unexpected (by me, anyway)
side bonus to eliminating acids from my darkroom in
order to abate smell production.

When no acid is carried into my KRST working solution,
I notice vastly less black precipitate. I can keep my
working solution almost water-clear by using paper
coffee filters to remove what little black stuff forms.

At first I reduced darkroom smell by changing from
acetic to citric acid stop baths. Soon my fixer
experiments led me to the path of least resistance:
Plain Fixer, as Ansel Adams calls it. (It's not
'plain'; it has sodium sulfite as well as sodium
thiosulfate.) Once the fixer had no acid, so the only
acid present was from the rinsed (there is no perfect
rinse!) print coming from the stop, I noticed a decline
in the black stuff in the KRST. After I replaced the
acid stop with plain water rinses (four; I know, it's
extreme. Extremely easy and cheap) the black stuff
nearly stopped. I filter my solution through a paper
coffee filter about once per darkroom session.
Sometimes I filter it both before and after I use it.
Stored in a container that permits examination of the
contents, it's easy to judge when to filter.

I love glass containers, and I'm sure it's the best for
storage of selenium toner. But sooner or later it gets
dropped ... I'd say if one uses glass, it should live
in the sink and never go out of the sink. Personally, I
use plastic.

regards,
--le
Signature

________________________________
Lloyd Erlick Portraits, Toronto.
voice: 416-686-0326
email: portrait@heylloyd.com
net: www.heylloyd.com
________________________________

Sam G - 27 Feb 2005 00:58 GMT
Everything I have read (and experienced) with this toner is that its life is
dependent upon the number of times the solution is used to tone not how long
it is sitting in  the bottle.  The tip off that it is losing its strength is
when the toning times get intolerably long.  I keep my diluted solution in a
heavy plastic bottle I salvaged from some other product.  When I get that
ocasional black stuff and it gets too bothersome I either slowly pour off
the solution from the bottle into the tray and rinse out the small amt left
in the bottle or pour the entire solution through a piece of coffee filter
paper.

Sam
.
Lloyd Erlick - 27 Feb 2005 13:58 GMT
feb2705 from Lloyd Erlick,

>Everything I have read (and experienced) with this toner is that its life is
>dependent upon the number of times the solution is used to tone not how long
>it is sitting in  the bottle.

Yes, I think so, too. It seems quite capable of sitting
in the bottle for a very long time, years and years,
apparently.

The tip off that it is losing its strength is
>when the toning times get intolerably long.

And when it's used fairly concentrated, (I dilute my
KRST 1+5 with distilled water) it takes a long time to
lose strength from use. It loses solution volume much
more quickly due to carry-out on the sheets of paper.
This means additional fresh working strength toner must
be added to top it up. So when a relatively strong KRST
solution is used, it's unlikely to suffer reduced
toning capability.

I keep my diluted solution in a
>heavy plastic bottle I salvaged from some other product.

Me too. Mine has a four inch wide mouth, and originally
held cat food. I like the wide mouth because I work
single-tray, so pouring the solution back into the jug
is quite easy with a four inch target. This way the
toner is in the tray only while toning a print, so the
smell of ammonia only has a few minutes to get around
my darkroom. Also, the toner is stored in its working
container. And the toner isn't in the tray long enough
to stain it.

When I get that
>ocasional black stuff and it gets too bothersome I either slowly pour off
>the solution from the bottle into the tray and rinse out the small amt left
>in the bottle or pour the entire solution through a piece of coffee filter
>paper.
>
>Sam

I've noticed over a long period of time that the black
stuff adhering to the walls of my KRST jug is reducing.
I've used this jug since before I gave up acid in the
darkroom, and it was pretty black at the bottom. Over
time the black is disappearing now that there is no
acid in my process.

regards,
--le
Signature

________________________________
Lloyd Erlick Portraits, Toronto.
voice: 416-686-0326
email: portrait@heylloyd.com
net: www.heylloyd.com
________________________________

Tom Phillips - 27 Feb 2005 20:35 GMT
> feb2705 from Lloyd Erlick,
>
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
> solution is used, it's unlikely to suffer reduced
> toning capability.

By using a stronger concentration you have more
toner and tones faster, but it would still suffer
reduced toning capability (both in time and capacity)
since the toning solution still gradually weakens as
you run prints through it. You're not maintaining a
true 1:5 dilution by topping it off, it's still
gradually getting weaker albeit slower than if you
didn't top it off. By using such a strong dilution
you likely just don't notice this.

There may be a difference in how well it keeps based
on the degree of dilution though, or how you store it.
I use it 1:9 and keep it in glass jars. I gradually
extend the toning time as the number of prints toned
increases. This is because to my knowledge there is no
way to determine the correct amount of fresh toner to
add/replenish in order to maintain the original toner
strength/dilution over time. So if with fresh toner
1:9 I tone for 3 minutes, that time gradually gets
extended as the toner weakens (i.e., I guess at the
time based on the intensity of the color change observed.)

>  I keep my diluted solution in a
> >heavy plastic bottle I salvaged from some other product.
[quoted text clipped - 33 lines]
> ________________________________
> --
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.