After a shocking experience with the all plastic Fiskars Rotary blade
trimmer, I am looking for recommendations for tools for cutting and trimming
photographs. Largest size paper is A3 (eg longest length), but will be
happy with 12" or 24" length.
Which is better, a guillotine or a trimmer.
Also prefer to be something that is desktop based, not large freestanding
unit.
Also any recommendations on brands/models and to places in Sydney to buy and
get sound advice.
Although the Fiskars unit has a metal guide, it has too much flex in it and
rarely provides a perfectly straight edge.
Fiskars 12" Home/Office Rotary Paper Trimmer
http://www.fiskars.com/US/Office/Product+Detail?contentId=91598
Colin D - 29 Mar 2006 23:34 GMT
> After a shocking experience with the all plastic Fiskars Rotary blade
> trimmer, I am looking for recommendations for tools for cutting and trimming
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> Fiskars 12" Home/Office Rotary Paper Trimmer
> http://www.fiskars.com/US/Office/Product+Detail?contentId=91598
I prefer a steel straightedge and a box-cutter or Stanley-style knife,
with one of those self-healing cutting mats. The big advantage is you
can place the ruler precisely over the image; you're not trying to see
where the knife-edge is under the print as you have to do with a
guillotine or rotary trimmer. Also, when cutting heavier material,
guillotines and rotary trimmers have a tendency to skew the item while
cutting, but this doesn't happen with a straightedge.
Colin D.
Pete D - 30 Mar 2006 10:09 GMT
My rotary cutter has a see through area that you press down on to keep it in
place and allows very precise cutting. Mine is the 45cm paper trimmer from
office works, large heavy and well made and cuts A3 photo paper beautifully
without marking the edge like mu old cutter did, it is model number LCV-45.
>> After a shocking experience with the all plastic Fiskars Rotary blade
>> trimmer, I am looking for recommendations for tools for cutting and
[quoted text clipped - 25 lines]
>
> Colin D.
mark.thomas.7@gmail.com - 30 Mar 2006 11:06 GMT
While there are cheap and good cars, cherap and good cameras, and even
cheap and fairly good printers, I've never yet seen a cheap good
guillotine.
I think the best ones are the big rotaries (usually free-standing!),
followed by the bigger heavy guillotines. But in either case, the key
factor for me is that it *must* in some way hold the subject down. The
more expensive ones (of either type) have quite ingeniously simple
safety locks and hold down bars that grip the paper securely and very
close to the edge. That is the one thing that makes the difference,
imo.
David Springthorpe - 30 Mar 2006 11:26 GMT
>While there are cheap and good cars, cherap and good cameras, and even
>cheap and fairly good printers, I've never yet seen a cheap good
>guillotine.
Are you in fact saying that the cheap ones "just don't cut
it".....(sorry) ?
mark.thomas.7@gmail.com - 30 Mar 2006 12:43 GMT
>Are you in fact saying that the cheap ones "just don't cut
>it".....(sorry) ?
David - go to your room! (O:
Don't come out until you come up with a *better* pun - one that papers
over the flaws in that one. Perhaps a much sharper wit is needed...?
(I would say something about "cutting edge humour", but that word has
already been taken, and so it would be bad form.)
Damn, now *I* have to go to my room!
David Springthorpe - 30 Mar 2006 12:57 GMT
>>Are you in fact saying that the cheap ones "just don't cut
>>it".....(sorry) ?
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
>Damn, now *I* have to go to my room!
It's my head on the block (best I could do), so I retire defeated.....
Poxy - 30 Mar 2006 13:35 GMT
>>> Are you in fact saying that the cheap ones "just don't cut
>>> it".....(sorry) ?
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
> It's my head on the block (best I could do), so I retire defeated.....
You must be losing your edge.
mark.thomas.7@gmail.com - 30 Mar 2006 13:53 GMT
>It's my head on the block (best I could do), so I retire defeated.....
Ah well, at least your fate was not as bad as that of Marie
Antoinette.. "Let them eat cake" I reckon..
And whichever way you slice that cake (how's that, a segue included at
no extra charge!!), this thread is now going downhill faster than a
guillotine blade.
Ok, enough. I'm going to sit here in my rocking chair, doing my
knitting, watching....
Rob - 31 Mar 2006 00:05 GMT
> After a shocking experience with the all plastic Fiskars Rotary blade
> trimmer, I am looking for recommendations for tools for cutting and trimming
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> Fiskars 12" Home/Office Rotary Paper Trimmer
> http://www.fiskars.com/US/Office/Product+Detail?contentId=91598
Dahle
http://www.abc-i.com/cutters_trimmers/rotary_trimmers.htm
Not the cheaper range.
James McNangle - 31 Mar 2006 03:38 GMT
>After a shocking experience with the all plastic Fiskars Rotary blade
>trimmer, I am looking for recommendations for tools for cutting and trimming
>photographs. Largest size paper is A3 (eg longest length), but will be
>happy with 12" or 24" length.
>Which is better, a guillotine or a trimmer.
I have an "Ideal" guillotine, of the type used by printers. Excluding the
handles, it is 590 mm deep, 510 mm wide and 250 mm high, and sits on a bench.
It is very heavy -- I can JUST lift it. The throat is 370 mm wide by 40 mm
high, and it has a paper clamp, and movable backstop. My late wife bought it
secondhand through some of her printing contacts for our former business, so I
have no idea what it cost. However you could ask your friendly printer, or look
for a printers supply company.
It is probably rather large and expensive for the home office, but I find it
invaluable. It will cut several hundred sheets at a time, so you can buy A4
photo paper and trim it to any suitable size, and you can readily make small
runs of business cards and the like.
Thoroughly recommended!
James McNangle