>> I somehow think no one actually got the message on the headstone. It's
>> been loud and clear for over 100 years.
>>
>> Doug
>
> What are we missing?
Both of his wives name was Jardine, while his name was Smith.
The fine print doesn't come across clearly on my screen, and I can't
enlarge the photo to look at it, so I can't tell for sure, but it looks
like the first wife died at age 55 in 1854, and the second wife died at
age 50 in 1857,
... and he was only 63 when HE died in 1900.
So he'd have been 20 when the first one died, and 23 when the second one
died ... and he lived another 43 years as a bachelor unless there's
still more wives buried somewhere else.
Looks like he married some old spinster and she died; so he married her
sister and then she died.
Hmmmmm? Arsenic and old lace anyone?
Walter Banks - 04 Sep 2007 19:24 GMT
> >> I somehow think no one actually got the message on the headstone. It's
> >> been loud and clear for over 100 years.
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
>
> Hmmmmm? Arsenic and old lace anyone?
My reading of the stone and got a different story. the Good doctor died in
1900 at 63 (born 1837 ) Agnes died in 1887 at 50 a similar age to the
Doctor in 1887. Matilda poor soul was laid to rest as the good doctors
wife seven years later in 1894 at 55 making her born in 1839. It is possible
that Matilda was Agnes's younger sister..
It is possible that the 5's I read were threes making the story even more
interesting.
Since ladies don't easily disclose their ages and tombstones may indistinct
or out of focus we have a ending with three stores.
Patrick, MD died 9 Dec 1900 after a long and interesting life.
D-mac whats the story here?
w.. :)
D_Mac - 05 Sep 2007 03:16 GMT
> > > In article <1188855789.204234.257...@r34g2000hsd.googlegroups.com>,
>
[quoted text clipped - 40 lines]
>
> w.. :)
OK...
How many marriages do you know where the male takes the wife's name -
twice?
In the 1800s Bigamy was a popular pastime for the wealthy in
Australia. Polygamy however was likely to get you tarred and
feathered. I haven't yet figured out how the three of them all lived
in the doctor's house for the length of his stay on the Island. It was
a Government provided house!
I've searched all through the BDM records for the colony (Stradbroke
was the quarantine station) and I can't find any record of either
marriage to the ladies buried with him. The good doctor was indeed
married but not to either of those women!
Doug
Pudentame - 05 Sep 2007 04:32 GMT
.
>> The fine print doesn't come across clearly on my screen, and I can't
>> enlarge the photo to look at it, so I can't tell for sure, but it looks
>> like the first wife died at age 55 in 1854, and the second wife died at
>> age 50 in 1857,
> My reading of the stone and got a different story. the Good doctor died in
> 1900 at 63 (born 1837 ) Agnes died in 1887 at 50 a similar age to the
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> It is possible that the 5's I read were threes making the story even more
> interesting.
Well, like I said, the fine print doesn't come across clearly on my screen.
Matthew Winn - 05 Sep 2007 09:05 GMT
> Both of his wives name was Jardine, while his name was Smith.
>
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
> ... and he was only 63 when HE died in 1900.
To me the dates look more like 1857 and 18_9_4. Comparing with other
9s and 5s, the bottom of the 5 swings further to the left than that of
the 9.
With the names of his wives being the same, perhaps he married a widow
and then married her daughter.

Signature
Matthew Winn
[If replying by mail remove the "r" from "urk"]